Assemini, 2.10.2013
Egregio
Lettore,
le confermo
innanzi tutto di avere espresso a suo tempo il parere
di cui link ha sopra indicato. Di
seguito troverà risposta al quesito che mi ha
sottoposto:
Decadrammo1,
Zecca di Siracusa, c. 460 a. C.
Descrizione sommaria:
D. Quadriga al passo verso destra, cavalli
incoronati da una Vittoria alata. In esergo un
leone.2
Bordo perlinato.
R. ΣΥRAKOSION.3
Testa femminile (Arethusa)4 incoronata
d'alloro all'interno di un sottile cerchio lineare,
all'esterno 4 delfini circondano la leggenda
precitata. Bordo lineare.
Dalla ricerca nel web ho ricavato i link che
seguono, il primo attinente ad un decadrammo
autentico in possesso del British Museum, il secondo
e il terzo attinenti a tetradrammi tipologicamente
affini alla moneta in esame, gli altri attinenti a
riproduzioni moderne del menzionato decadrammo:
- http://www.britishmuseum.org/images/ps173914_l.jpg
Silver decadrachm of Syracuse Weight: 44.430 g CM
BMC Syracuse 63 Greeks in Italy Silver decadrachm
of Syracuse Greek, around 460 BC From Syracuse,
Sicily. This may be the so-called Demareteion of
Syracuse. The first half of the fifth century BC
in Sicily was characterised in several cities by
the rise of powerful tyrants. In the city of
Syracuse, the greatest of the tyrants was Gelon.
In 480 BC Gelon brought to an end the rivalry
between Carthaginians and Greeks on the island of
Sicily with a decisive defeat of the Carthaginian
forces at the Battle of Himera. Gelon's wife,
Demarete, was instrumental in the peace settlement
that followed. According to the later Greek
historian, Diodorus of Sicily, Demarete received a
crown of one hundred gold talents from the
Carthaginians. He tells us that in celebration
'she struck a coin which was called after a
Demareteion: it was worth ten Attic drachmas'. For
a long time the Demareteion that Diodorus mentions
was assumed by scholars to be the silver coin
shown here, since it is the earliest known
ten-drachma coin (decadrachm) produced at
Syracuse. On the front of the coin is a chariot
drawn by four horses (a quadriga) with a figure of
Nike, and a lion running below. On the other side
is the head of the nymph Arethusa, surrounded by
dolphins and the Greek legend 'of the Syracusans'.
Certainly the quality of engraving of the design
is markedly higher than on accompanying
tetradrachm coins, suggesting this to be a
particularly important issue. More recent
numismatic research has shown, however, that the
coin must be dated at least twenty years after the
Battle of Himera. The Demareteion coins that
Diodorus describes thus remain something of a
puzzle.
- http://www.magnagraecia.nl/coins/Area_IV_map/Syracusa_map/jpgs/SyrB_375_ha.jpg
dekadrachm (Demareteion) of Syracuse, 465 BC ca
obv. slow quadriga, horses crowned by Nike Rev.
head of female (Arethusa), 4 dolphins around
SURAKOSION Boehringer 375 42.29 g Numismatica Ars
Classica AG, Auction 13 8th October 1998 no. 433
Ex Antikenmuseum Basel und Sammlung Ludwig no.
433.
- Roma
Numismatics Ltd Auction 6 Session
2 Auction date: 29 September 2013 Lot
number: 442 Price realized: To Be Posted
Find similar lots in upcoming auctions
at NumisBids.com Lot description:
Sicily, Syracuse AR Tetradrachm.
Deinomenid Tyranny. Time of Hieron I,
circa 475-470 BC. Dies by the
Demareteion Master. Charioteer wearing a
long chiton and holding a goad in his
right hand and the reins in his left,
driving a walking quadriga to right;
Nike above, flying right to crown the
horses; below, lion springing to right
in exergue / Head of Arethusa right
within linear circle, wearing olive
wreath, pendant earring and necklace;
her hair waved at the front and tied at
the back with a ribbon; ΣVRAKOΣION and
four dolphins swimming clockwise around.
Boehringer 382 (V196/R269); Rizzo pl.
XXXV, 4 var.; SNG ANS -. 17.32g, 26mm,
6h. Insignificant mark on reverse,
otherwise Extremely Fine. Very Rare.
From the Comery Collection. The series
of coins known as the Demareteia are
among the most famous and revered of all
the ancient coins, being acclaimed as
masterpieces of late archaic art. The
engraver responsible for the series, the
'Demareteion Master' is rightly placed
among the first rank of accomplished
artists. The series takes its name from
queen Demarete, wife of the Syracusan
tyrant Gelon, who Diodoros (XI. 26)
reports as having intervened on behalf
of the defeated Carthaginians at the
peace negotiations following the Battle
of Himera: 'For when the ambassadors who
had been dispatched from Carthage came
to him and begged him with tears to
treat them humanely, he granted them
peace, exacting of them the expense he
had incurred for the war, two thousand
talents of silver, and requiring them
further to build two temples in which
they should place copies of the treaty.
The Carthaginians, having unexpectedly
gained their deliverance, not only
agreed to all this but also promised to
give in addition a gold crown to
Demarete, the wife of Gelon. For
Demarete at their request had
contributed the greatest aid toward the
conclusion of the peace, and when she
had received the crown of one hundred
gold talents from them, she struck a
coin which was called from her a
Damareteion. This was worth ten Attic
drachmas and was called by the Sicilian
Greeks, according to its weight, a
pentekontalitron.' The identity of the
coin Diodoros mentions has long
presented a mystery, fiercely debated,
since the crown was said to be of gold
and there were no known gold coins of
Syracuse until many years later. At
various times it has been claimed that
Diodoros must have been referring to a
gold issue of which no specimens
survive, or another silver coin with
which we are not familiar. Yet he
specifically mentions the denomination
and standard of the coin, and the case
for the companion dekadrachm of this
type being the coin referred to by
Diodoros can no longer be seriously
disputed. Though we shall not present
here arguments relating to the dating of
the series, the consensus is that the
coin was struck some time after the
Battle of Himera, most likely under
Hieron, with the date range proposed by
Alföldi, E. Boehringer and
Arnold-Biucchi of 475-470 seming the
most plausible. The superior style and
workmanship of the coin certainly
appears to commemorate a victory, noting
in particular the extraordinary presence
of a laurel wreath adorning Arethusa;
yet a purely commemorative nature for
this coin is probably a simplistic and
naive interpretation. The dekadrachms
struck by Dionysios I are now agreed to
have been intended to pay for
mercenaries; the theory that the
Athenian dekadrachms were struck in
commemoration of the victory over the
Persians at Marathon or Salamis too has
been discredited. We should see in the
Demareteion series a product of
expedience - a means of paying mercenary
soldiers - which though presented in a
remarkable form is nonetheless an
economic solution rather than a
commemorative frivolity. Estimate: 50000
GBP.
- Numismatica
Ars Classica Auction 72 Auction date: 16 May
2013 Lot number: 324 Price realized: 110,000
CHF (approx. 113,695 USD as of the auction
date) Note: Prices do not include
buyer's fees.Find similar lots in upcoming
auctions at NumisBids.com Lot description:
Greek Coins Syracuse. Tetradrachm of the
Demareteion series circa 465, AR 17.80 g. Slow
quadriga driven r. by charioteer, wearing chiton
and holding reins in both hands and kentron in l.;
above, Nike flying r. to crown the horses. In
exergue, lion running r. Rev. ΣV – RA – KOΣΙ – Ο –
N Head of Arethusa r., wearing olivewreath,
earring and necklace, framed within a circle and
surrounded by four dolphins swimming clockwise.
Rizzo pl. XXXV, 6. AMB 434 (these dies).
Boehringer 386.1 (this coin illustrated). Very
rare and in exceptional condition for this very
difficult and prestigious issue. A wonderful old
cabinet tone and of superb style, minor
oxidations, otherwise extremely fine. Ex Leu sale
76, 1999, 54. From the collection of the Money
Museum of Zürich. In recent decades the dates of
numerous ancient coins, including the celebrated
works attributed to the Demareteion Master, have
been reconsidered. These coins had traditionally
been placed in 480 or 479 B.C. based upon an
historical association derived from a passage in
the eleventh book of Diodorus Siculus. However,
the numismatic component of his account, which was
composed 450 years after the events described,
appears flawed, and current thought places these
coins firmly between c.470 and c.460 B.C. Diodorus
records the generous terms for peace given by the
Syracusan tyrant Gelon to the Carthaginians, who
in 480 B.C. the Greeks had just defeated at the
Battle of Himera. He reports that the
Carthaginians were asked to pay only the costs of
war incurred by the Greeks, two thousand talents
of silver, and to build two temples in which
copies of the treaty were to be preserved. That
report is followed by the passage relevant to the
Demareteion decadrachm: "The Carthaginians, having
unexpectedly gained their deliverance, not only
agreed to all this but also promised to give in
addition a gold crown to Demarete, the wife of
Gelon. For Demarete at their request had
contributed the greatest aid toward the conclusion
of the peace, and when she had received the crown
of one hundred gold talents from them, she struck
a coin which was called from her a Demareteion.
This was worth ten Attic drachmas and was called
by the Sicilian Greeks, according to its weight, a
pentekontalitron [a fifty-litra piece]." (XI 26.3)
In his 1969 work The Demareteion and Sicilian
Chronology, Kraay challenged the notion current
since 1830 that the decadrachm mentioned by
Diodorus was the first issue of silver decadrachms
at Syracuse. Beyond the fact that the passage
suggests the coins would have been made of gold,
Kraay objected on numismatic grounds to so early a
date for the first decadrachm. He noted how its
incorrect date of c.480/79 B.C. had become "the
sheet-anchor of Sicilian numismatic chronology"
and, consequently, had skewed ideas on the
chronologies of so many other coinages. Moreover,
Kraay notes that the appearance of the leaping
lion on two issues of Leontini tetradrachms had
led some to assume that the tyrant of Leontini
must have played a role at the Battle of Himera.
However, literary sources record no such
involvement, and if this coinage was disassociated
with the victory at Himera, the only connection
needed between the Demareteion issues of Syracuse
and Leontini would be of a numismatic character.
It is now believed that the earliest possible date
for the Demareteion decadrachm is c.470 B.C., and
that it more likely was struck in about 465 B.C.
The same may be said for the associated
tetradrachms of Syracuse that Kraay notes exhibit
"the same peculiarities of style and design" as
the decadrachm. Kraay initially had narrowed the
timeframe for the decadrachm to c.466-461 B.C.,
between the expulsion of the tyrant Hieron I from
Syracuse and the removal of foreign mercenaries
from the city in 461, and a few years later had
settled upon c.465 B.C. Estimate: 80000 CHF.
- http://www.forumancientcoins.com/fakes/displayimage.php?pos=-4277
Syracuse, Sicily, AR modern electrotype copy.
Syracuse, Sicily, AR modern electrotype copy,
Silver dekadrachm, Copy of a British Museum
example of the c. 466 masterpiece by the
Demaretion Master; Boehringer 376; BMC 63
(original of this coin), 34.285g, 33.0mm, 180o,
1930’s era; obverse Male charioteer wearing a long
chiton, goad in right, reins in left, walking
quadriga to right, Nike above flying right crowns
horses; lion springing to right in ex; reverse
SURAKOSION, Head of Arethusa to r., wearing olive
wreath, pendant earring and necklace; hair waved
at front and turned up at back; linear circle
around and four dolphins swimming clockwise.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=70036
Source Jean Elsen & ses Fils S.A.
Auction 98 (13.12.2008) Lot 44 (
« | » ) Price 600 EUR (~820
USD) Description SICILE, SYRACUSE, AR
décadrachme par le maître du Démareteion,
Reproduction moderne. Droit : Quadrige
couronné par Niké volant à droite, mené au pas
par un aurige. A l'exergue, lion courant à
droite. Revers : Tête l. de nymphe à droite,
dans un cercle linéaire, entourée de quatre
dauphins. Ref.: Boehringer, type 376. 36,02g.
Petit poinçon MB au bas du droit. Très Beau.
VF.
- http://www.forumancientcoins.com/fakes/displayimage.php?pos=-12792
Syracuse, Sicily, dekadrachm Submitted to Spanish
Forum Imperio-Numismatico for verification.
Apr_2011AR Dekadrachm, Demaretion, 35 mm Obv: Slow
quadriga driven right by malr charioteer holding
goad; above, Nike flying right, crowning horses;
in exg, lion springing right REv: ΣV/RA/KOΣ/ION
around linear circle, within which head of
Artemis-Arethusa right, wearing olive-wreath;
around, four dolphins. Boehringer #376; BMC
Sicily, #63; Sear #92.
- http://www.forumancientcoins.com/fakes/displayimage.php?pos=-502
Syracuse, silver dekadrachm, 063. AR dekadrachm,
Demaretion Slow quadriga driven right by malr
charioteer holding goad; above, Nike flying right,
crowning horses; in exg, lion springing right /
ΣVRAKOΣION around linear circle, within which head
of Artemis-Arethusa right, wearing olive-wreath;
around, four dolphins. BMC Sicily, 63; Sear 920.
Sold on Ebay as a reproduction. "Copy" stamped on
rim. Submitted by Bluefish.
- http://www.forumancientcoins.com/fakes/displayimage.php?pos=-1888
Syracuse, silver dekadrachm, 063 AR dekadrachm,
the Demaretion. Modern forgery. Slow quadriga
driven right by malr charioteer holding goad;
above, Nike flying right, crowning horses; in exg,
lion springing right / ΣVRAKOΣION around linear
circle, within which head of Artemis-Arethusa
right, wearing olive-wreath; around, four dolphins
BMC Sicily, 63; Sear 920 Purchased at auction
April 2005. Once identified as fake the seller
refunded buyer's money.
Concludo rimarcando che la moneta in esame è una copia
esatta della moneta di cui a suo tempo mi ero occupato
(v. link) e di cui, a
quel che vedo, si è occupato anche il forum di
numismatica lamoneta.it.
Rispetto alla precedente valutazione la novità è
determinata dall'attuale disponibilità di dati sicuri
sulle caratteristiche fisiche della moneta del lettore
(peso, diametro, acclarata ferromagneticità del
tondello) e dalla disponibilità in rete di un'immagine
del decadrammo in possesso del British Museum che è
servita per il confronto con la moneta in esame.
Un saluto cordiale.
Giulio De Florio
Note:
(1) Il decadrammo
di Siracusa della serie Demareiton, tipologicamente
affine alla moneta in esame, è una moneta d'argento
di eccezionale rarità, del peso di circa 44g della
quale è stato possibile reperire in rete il solo
esemplare nella disponibilità del British Museum
(cliccare sul link1 per
osservarne l'immagine). La moneta di cui al link2 è anch'essa un decadrammo
autentico di Siracusa, il suo peso è di circa 42g ma
differisce per la foggia dei capelli dal decadrammo
del British Museum. Le monete di cui ai link3 e link4
sono nominali di taglio inferiore, tetradrammi cioè,
del peso di circa 17g, tipologicamente simili alla
moneta del British Museum ma il tipo differisce per
alcuni particolari del disegno dal decadrammo del
British Museum (cito ad esempio le zampe anteriori
dei cavalli o la forma dei capelli nel rovescio),
oltre che per il peso. Le altre monete presenti nei
link sopra citati sono tutte repliche del decadrammo
del British in quanto ne condividono il disegno,
certo non lo stile, né il peso e forse nemmeno la
composizione della lega. La moneta in possesso del
lettore è tipologicamente simile al decadrammo e
alle monete non autentiche precitate, non possiede
lo stile e il peso del decadrammo e, sopra tutto, la
lega non è d'argento, data la presenza di ferro nel
tondello dichiarata dal lettore.
(2) Le note che seguono traducono
liberamente il commento a corredo dell'immagine della
moneta del British Museum: "La prima metà del V secolo
a. C. fu caratterizzata in diverse città della Sicilia
dalla crescita di potenti tiranni. Nella città di
Siracusa, il più grande dei tiranni fu Gelone. Nel 480
a. C. Gelone pose fine alla rivalità tra Cartaginesi e
Greci nell'isola di Sicilia infliggendo una sconfitta
decisiva alle forze cartaginesi nella battaglia di
Imera. La moglie di Gelone, Demarete, fu determinante
nell'accordo di pace che ne seguì. Secondo lo storico
greco, Diodoro Siculo, vissuto in epoca successiva,
Demarete ricevette dai Cartaginesi una corona d'oro
del valore di cento talenti. Egli riferisce che, in
ricordo dell'evento, ella ordinò la coniazione di una
moneta che fu poi chiamata Demareteion, del valore di
dieci dracme attiche. Per lungo tempo il Demareteion
citato da Diodoro fu considerato dagli studiosi essere
proprio la moneta d'argento qui illustrata, dal
momento che si tratta del decadrammo più antico
prodotto a Siracusa. Sul dritto della moneta si
osserva un carro trainato da quattro cavalli
(quadriga) con una figura di Nike, e un leone di corsa
a destra in esergo. Sull'altro lato c'è la testa della
ninfa Aretusa, circondata da delfini e la leggenda
greca 'dei Siracusani'. Certamente la qualità
dell'incisione è nettamente superiore rispetto a
quella che accompagna i tetradrammi, suggerendo che si
tratti in questo caso di un'emissione particolarmente
importante. Studi numismatici più recenti hanno
dimostrato tuttavia che la moneta deve essere datata
almeno 20 anni dopo la battaglia di Imera. I
Demareteion che Diodoro descrive rimangono quindi una
sorta di puzzle." Per un approfondimento del tema
rimando al link
http://www.writer2001.com/fick.htm. Nel link3 si sostiene che attribuire
alla moneta un carattere puramente commemorativo in
virtù del pregio artistico dell'incisione sia
probabilmente semplicistico e ingenuo. Oggi si crede
che i decadrammi battuti da Dionisio I fossero serviti
a pagare i mercenari; anche la teoria che i decadrammi
ateniesi fossero stati battuti in commemorazione della
vittoria sui Persiani a Maratona e Salamina è stata
abbandonata. Dovremmo vedere, anche nella serie
Demareteion, un prodotto di convenienza - un mezzo
utile per pagare i soldati - anche se battuto in una
veste artistica di grande pregio.
(3)
ΣΎRAKOΣION (=dei Siracusani) è l'etnico, il
popolo nel nome del quale la moneta fu battuta.
Riprendo dal portale dell'Enciclopedia Treccani on
line (v. link)
le note storiche che seguono concernenti il periodo:
"Siracusa fu fondata nel 734-33 a.C. da coloni greci
di Corinto nell’isola di Ortigia (Siracusa). La città
fondò presto colonie nell’interno della Sicilia, tra
cui Acre, la più antica. Nel 6° sec. Siracusa era
governata da un’aristocrazia di γαμόροι (proprietari
terrieri) a cui obbediva il demo; privi dei diritti
politici erano invece i cilliri o cilliciri,
discendenti dalle popolazioni indigene assoggettate.
Nel 5° sec. Gelone, membro della famiglia dei
Dinomenidi di Gela, si impadronì di Siracusa, la unì a
Gela e vi assunse i pieni poteri. Distrusse la ribelle
Camarina e, con il tiranno di Agrigento, Terone, vinse
i Cartaginesi a Imera (480).
(4) Aretusa è il simbolo
dell'autorità statuale di Siracusa impresso sulla
moneta (come è avvenuto nel passato italico recente
quando il simbolo statuale dell'Italia era
rappresentato da un personaggio femminile con il capo
coperto da corona turrita - v. link).
Nel caso dell'antica Siracusa la scelta come simbolo
dell'Aretusa trova ispirazione nel mito di cui di
seguito fornisco una breve sintesi (v. anche il link):
"Aretusa, ninfa al seguito di Artemide, mentre si
bagnava nelle acque del fiume Alfeo del Peloponneso
(v. mappa),
fu vista dall'omonimo dio fluviale che,
invaghitosene, si propose di tenerla con sé. Per
sfuggirgli, Aretusa riparò ad Ortigia, l'isoletta
che fronteggia Siracusa; lì Artemide, nell'intento
di proteggerla, la trasformò in fonte. Alfeo allora,
non volendo perderla, attraversò il mare nella forma
di fiume e unì le sue acque a quelle che sgorgavano
dalla fonte".
|