Roma, 11.4.2020
Egregio Lettore
riporto di seguito gli elementi significativi
riguardanti la moneta di figura:
Tetradrammo1,
zecca di Siracusa, c. 405 a. C., BMC II
209 (pag. 177)
Descrizione sommaria (sono indicate in rosso le
parti della leggenda usurate o comunque non più
leggibili):
D. Testa frontale, leggermente inclinata a sinistra
di ninfa, adorna di orecchini e collana; capelli che
si irradiano dalla testa in trecce sciolte; benda
sulla fronte, firmata ΚΙΜΩΝ2;
intorno, due delfini per ciascun lato, che nuotano
tra le ciocche: bordo perlinato, metà inferiore del
quale a doppio colpo: sopra, fuori bordo, ΑΡΕΘΟΣΑ3.
R. Quadriga4
veloce a sinistra con cavalli impennati, guidata da
auriga che, con pungolo nella mano destra, tocca il
capo del terzo cavallo, redini trattenute con
entrambe le mani. Sopra, Nike in volo a destra, in
procinto di incoronare l'auriga;
ΚΙΜΩΝ tra le due linee
d'esergo: ΣΥΡAKOΣIΩN5 in
esergo. Sotto spiga di grano. Bordo lineare.
La ricerca nel web di monete della tipologia di
figura ha dato luogo ai seguenti risultati:
- https://collections.mfa.org/objects/874
Tetradrachm of Syracuse with head of Arethusa,
signed by Kimon Greek Classical Periodc.
413–399 B.C.Mint: Sicily, Syracuse
MEDIUM/TECHNIQUE Silver DIMENSIONS Diameter:
28mm. Weight: 16.30gm. CREDIT LINE Catharine
Page Perkins Fund ACCESSION NUMBER 00.117
CATALOGUE RAISONNÉ Brett, Greek Coins (MFA),
no. 0417. DESCRIPTION: Obverse: Head of
Arethusa, almost full-front to left, with
earring and necklace; flowing hair, with a
diadem on which are said to be traces of Kimon
in Greek (see Brett catalogue, no. 417).
Traces of inscription in Greek above to name
the nymph (also Brett, no. 417). Around the
head are four dolphins among the tresses.
Border of dots. Reverse: Quadriga with horses
galloping to left and charioteer bent forward.
Nike flies to right to crown the charioteer.
In exergue: inscription in Greek above ear of
barley. Plain border. PROVENANCE: By date
unknown: Edward Herbert Bunbury Collection; by
1896: with Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge, 13
Wellington Street, Strand, London (auction of
the Edward Herbert Bunbury Collection, 13
Wellington Street, Strand, London, June 17,
1896, lot 465); by date unknown: with Edward
Perry Warren; 1900: purchased by MFA from
Edward Perry Warren.
- https://www.harvardartmuseums.org/art/195290
Identification and Creation Object Number
1972.216 People Designed by Kimon, Greek (415
- 400 BCE) Title Tetradrachm of Syracuse with
facing Arethusa by Kimon Classification Coins
Work Type coin. Date 406 BCE-405 B.C. Places
Creation Place: Ancient & Byzantine World,
Europe, Syracuse (Sicily). Period Classical
period, High Culture Greek. Persistent Link
https://hvrd.art/o/195290. LocationLevel 3,
Room 3200, Ancient Mediterranean and Near
Eastern Art, Classical Medium Silver Metal AR
Technique Struck Dimensions 17.26g Die Axis 11
Denomination tetradrachm Inscriptions and
Marks Obverse Inscription: KIMON; above (off
flan) APETOSA State, Edition, Standard
Reference Number Standard Reference Number
Tudeer 80 (O29 R53) Acquisition and Rights
Credit Line Harvard Art Museums/Arthur M.
Sackler Museum, Bequest of Frederick M.
Watkins. Accession Year 1972 Object Number
1972.216 Division Asian and Mediterranean Art.
Descriptions: Obverse: Head of Arethusa in
three quarter view to left surrounded by
dolphins. Reverse: quadriga of horses
galloping to l., driver crowned by small Nike;
in exergue ear of wheat.
- https://www.acsearch.info/search.html?id=1829983
Gemini, LLC http://www.geminiauction.com/
Auction XI 10 12.01.2014 Description: Sicily.
Syracuse. 406/5 BC. Tetradrachm, 16.16g. (h).
Obv: Three-quarter facing head of Arethusa,
artist's signature ΚΙΜΩΝ on headband. Dotted
border. Above, [ΑΡΕΘΟΣΑ]. Rx: Racing quadriga
left, Nike flying right above, crowning
driver; artist's signature ΚΙΜΩΝ on exergual
line. In exergue, wheat ear and ΣΥΡΑΚΟΣΙΩΝ.
Tudeer 80. Jameson Coll. 1835. SNG Oxford
2004. Nanteuil Coll. 358. For the meaning of
the obverse type, see W. Fischer-Bossert in S.
Vogt (ed.), Gedenkschrift Manfred Gutgesell
(forthcoming). Some reverse porosity. A
significant amount of horn silver has been
removed from this coin since the 2011 Hirsch
sale. EF/VF+. Ex Gemini X, 13 January 2013,
lot 21. Ex G. Hirsch 275, 22-23 September
2011, lot 3289. Ex M&M 79, 28 February and
1 March, 1994, lot 186. Kimon’s facing
Arethusa is one of the most famous head
designs of antiquity, rivaling even the
Arethusa of Euainetos’ decadrachm. Like the
latter, Kimon’s facing Arethusa was quickly
adopted by other mints in Sicily and abroad,
as well as by vase painters and metal workers.
The design’s adoption even in remote areas
such as Lycia and Cilicia shows that it got to
the heart. The point is not in the boldness to
show a head 3/4 facing to the observer – this
idea had been in the wind for many years,
though mainly among vase painters. The
revolutionary attraction is in the facial
expression that gives voice to a new
philosophy of life. In archaic and early
classical times, heads looking to front were
used by both vase painters and sculptors for
characterizing dying and dead warriors, as
well as monsters like the Gorgons. Then,
facing heads were something scary. Heads about
to turn around, thus seen in three-quarter
perspective, only came into fashion in early
classical times, c. 470 BC. Judging from the
scenarios they were used in, they are thought
to characterize a process of reasoning, or a
sophisticated perception like listening to
music. Kimon’s facing Arethusa, however, is
totally different. The nymph is not acting as
a mythological being, executing her role in
the myth told about her and the river god
Alpheios. She is not acting at all, but merely
presenting herself to the observer, thereby
enjoying herself rather than executing a role.
This design appears to be the earliest
forerunner of a new view of the Greek gods. In
fifth century art, the gods were acting
beings, engaged in human affairs. In fourth
century art, the gods kept to themselves,
enjoying their divine sphere, and no longer
dealing with human trifles. On the one hand,
this development accords with old Greek
thinking, expressed as early as Homer who
spoke of the “easy-living gods”. On the other,
this view of the gods is totally new, and
revolutionary. The old gnawing doubt as to
whether deities were really controlling human
affairs, thereby setting moral standards and
balancing out the many great injustices of
human life, forced its way into Greek
philosophy during the fifth and fourth
centuries, thus leading to new designs in
Greek art. So Kimon’s facing Arethusa is
likely to be the first, and most influential,
predecessor of masterpieces of fourth century
art like Praxiteles’ Cnidian Aphrodite and
Olympian Hermes. The short die chain this coin
belongs to consists of just four dies, two
obverse dies and two reverse dies, three of
which were signed by Kimon, and the fourth one
made by him, too. The obverse die of our coin
(Tudeer’s O29) might be the prototype; the
late Leo Mildenberg demonstrated that Tudeer’s
arrangement must be modified, thereby putting
O29 first and O28 second. The reverse die
(R53) is a highly sophisticated variant of a
famous Catanean model, the tetradrachm made by
Kimon’s rival Euainetos. Surprisingly in view
of its importance – the influence that both
the obverse and the reverse types were to
exert on contemporaneous coinages, and the
high esteem this die pair enjoys among coin
collectors and connoisseurs of art – the die
pair is extremely rare. Tudeer knew five
specimens in 1913, just one of them in private
hands (the Jameson coin that was to come up
again in the Hunt Collection). Since then only
three or four more specimens have emerged, one
of them in the Ognina Hoard.
- https://www.lamoneta.it/uploads/monthly_05_2014/post-7204-0-75292200-1399713888_thumb.jpg
https://www.lamoneta.it/uploads/monthly_05_2014/post-7204-0-05874000-1399714040_thumb.jpg
ex Pennisi museo di Siracusa 17,25g 2h.
- https://www.lamoneta.it/uploads/monthly_04_2014/post-7204-0-85888100-1398461821.jpg
NAC 54/2010, n. 56 17,37g (che ha realizzato
210.000 CHF).
- https://www.lamoneta.it/uploads/monthly_04_2014/post-7204-0-11053400-1398461848.jpg
New York Sale 30/2013, n. 55 (ex Jameson 822)
17,15g, 12h (che ha realizzato 180.000
dollari).
- https://www.lamoneta.it/uploads/monthly_04_2014/post-7204-0-40951100-1398461892_thumb.jpg
Paris, Luynes 1226 16,94g (con la solita
pesante patina da antica collezione museale).
- https://www.acsearch.info/search.html?id=170597
Numismatica Ars Classica NAC AG
http://www.arsclassicacoins.com/ Auction 27
118 12.05.2004 Description: Greek Coins
Syracuse No.: 118 Estimate: CHF 100000.
d=29mm. Tetradrachm signed by Kimon circa
405-400, AR 16.82g. Head of Arethusa facing
three-quarters l. wearing pearl-shaped pendant
and necklace over collier ornamented with
pearls; hair flowing in loose tresses; across
her forehead ampyx on which the signature
K[IMW]N. Around, three dolphins emerging from
curls and the fourth swimming downwards.
Above, outside linear border, AREQ [OSA]. In
field l., SW. Rev. Quadriga at speed with
prancing horses driven l. by chiton-clad
charioteer, holding kentron in r. hand and
reins in l.; above, Nike flying r. to crown
him. On exergual line, KIMWN. In exergue,
SURAKOSIWN / ear of barley l. Rizzo pl. 48, 11
(these dies). Kraay-Hirmer 123 (this obverse
die), 122 (this reverse die). Boston 417
(these dies). Regling 589 (this obverse die),
590 (this reverse die). Jameson 822 (these
dies). De Luynes 1226 (these dies). H. Cahn,
Essays Carson-Jenkins, Arethusa Soteira, 1
(this coin). Extremely rare. An attractive
specimen of this prestigious and desirable
issue with an enchanting representation of
Arethusa in sublime classical style. A
masterpiece from the most celebrated Sicilian
die-engraver. Struck on sound metal with an
exceptionally clear obverse, which allows for
the first time the reading of the letters SW.
About extremely fine. Ex Sotheby's sale 1990,
The Hunt collection part III, 24. Certainly
among the most influential coinages of the
ancient Greeks, this set of dies rank among
Kimon's finest. The obverse offers an
arresting portrait of the nymph Arethusa,
whose placid countenance is a foil to the hive
of activity that surrounds it (and to the
energetic scene on the reverse). First to
catch the viewer's attention is Arethusa's
hair, which flows wildly in all directions,
though not to the detriment of her appeal;
indeed, the fact that it flows back permits an
unobstructed view of her beauty. Four dolphins
artfully intertwine with the strands of
Arethusa's hair: one at the right is shown in
full, one at the left is nearly full, and only
the faces of the remaining two are shown, one
at each side. Kimon imparts a "playful
quality" to these dolphins - a naturalistic
triumph considering that is one of the most
endearing features of these sea mammals. Even
the dotted border is of interest, as it
restrains the expansive power of Arethusa's
image. Perhaps most masterful of all, though,
is how Kimon incorporates three inscriptions
into the design. His signature appears on the
ampyx that restrains the nymph's hair; her
name, Arethusa, is creatively placed at the
top outside the border; and an abbreviation
for "savior" is so cleverly hidden among the
dolphins and the strands of hair at the left
that it was not acknowledged until very
recently (H.A. Cahn, "Arethusa Soteira",
Essays in honour of Robert Carson and Kenneth
Jenkins, 1993, pp. 5-6). The reverse is
equally masterful, and the micro-signature on
the exergual line reveals it also is the work
of Kimon. Here we observe a quadriga in high
action, viewed at a slight angle, which
allowed the artist to demonstrate his ability
to convey perspective. Here, it would seem, we
have a momentary snapshot of a victorious team
turning the bend: the calm and confidence of
the driver, with his firm grip on the reins
and his gentle command of the goad, is a foil
to the wild excess of the horses, which rear
up and toss their heads in all directions.
Clearly Kimon captured a moment when a driver
performs and unconventional, but masterful
action that catches his team by surprise, yet,
was necessary to secure a victory, as
symbolized by the crowning of the driver by
Nike. We may note that the border is a thin,
solid line that does not distract us from the
powerful scene; Kimon even delights in
allowing the hoofs of the lead horse to break
through the border. The combination of the
obverse depicting "Arethusa the Savior" and
the reverse dedicated to a victorious
charioteer, and the remarkable quality of the
dies, earmarks this as a commemorative issue.
As such, it has been associated with
historical events, principally the defeat of
the Athenian fleet at Syracuse in 413 B.C.
and, perhaps more likely, the good fate of the
Syracusans in the otherwise devastating
invasion of Sicily by the Carthaginians from
406 to 405 B.C.
Conclusioni: All'asta di Numismatica Genevensis SA
Auction 11 del 18 November 2019 (v. link),
un tetradrammo d'argento firmato Cimone, già della
collezione Robert Käppeli (acquistato prima del
1960) è stato battuto per circa un milione mezzo
di euro. Un tetradrammo autentico di Cimone è il
vanto di pochi grandi musei ed il privilegio di un
ristretto numero di privati in grado di investire
somme eccezionali in un'asta internazionale. Ma
veniamo alla moneta di figura: dopo aver raccolto
nel web le immagini di un certo numero di campioni autentici della tipologia
di figura, ho realizzato in una tabella
riassuntiva il confronto
sinottico con la moneta di figura. Dal
confronto emerge che la moneta in esame, priva di
spessore e carente nei dettagli, al di là delle
carenze evidenziate nella nota1,
è una pallida replica di un originale antico.
Aggiungerò che gli esemplari autentici oggi in
mano ai privati sono tutti accompagnati da un
pedigree documentabile. Escludo pertanto che la
moneta in esame possa essere autentica.
Un saluto cordiale
Giulio De Florio
----------
(1)
Tetradrammo (Argento). Raccolgo in tabella le
caratteristiche fisiche dei tetradrammi della
tipologia di figura tratti
dai link di cui sopra:
Riferimenti |
Peso(g.) |
Diametro(mm) |
Asse di conio (H) |
Link1 |
16,30 |
28 |
- |
Link2 |
17,26 |
- |
11 |
Link3 |
16,16 |
- |
- |
Link4 |
17,25 |
- |
2 |
Link5 |
17,37 |
- |
- |
Link6 |
17,15 |
- |
12 |
Link7 |
16,94 |
- |
- |
Link8 |
16,82 |
29 |
- |
Link9 |
17,24 |
- |
- |
Link10 |
17,26 |
- |
- |
Dalla tabella si evince che le dimensioni della
moneta in esame (17,90g, 27mm, 6) rientrano in
grandi linee nei margini di variabilità delle
monete dello stesso tipo presenti nel web.
Qualche dubbio insorge sulla lega metallica del
tondello, supposto in argento ma nel quale, tra
le pieghe del collo, dei capelli e del contorno
del viso, affiorano zone di colore verde,
probabile conseguenza del cancro del rame.
(2) Cimone (in greco
ΚΙΜΩΝ), è stato un
medaglista greco (v. wikipedia),
attivo a Siracusa nel periodo 415 - 400 a.C.,
facente parte del ristretto numero di incisori
dell'antichità di cui si conosce il nome,
tramandato dalla firma sulle monete. Cimone fu
il creatore del decadrammo coniato a Siracusa
dopo la battaglia dell'Asinaro e il primo
incisore a disegnare la testa frontale di
Aretusa che caratterizza la monetazione di
Siracusa. Nella firma, come in altri dettagli,
ha mostrato la capacità di lavorare su
particolari minuti.
(3) ΑΡΕΘΟΣΑ.
Aderendo ad una consuetudine piuttosto diffusa
nelle città greche di Sicilia, Siracusa assunse,
come emblema, la divinità fluviale di
pertinenza, e dunque Aretusa. In proposito
riprendo la voce relativa del portale
dell'Enciclopedia Treccani on line (v. link):
"Aretusa è la ninfa della fonte che sgorga
nell’isola Ortigia (Siracusa). Una sorgente
omonima nell’Elide (Peloponneso), lungo il corso
inferiore del fiume Alfeo, fece nascere la
leggenda secondo cui Aretusa, ninfa del seguito
di Artemide, insidiata dal dio del fiume Alfeo,
riuscì a passare in Ortigia, dove fu raggiunta
da Alfeo che, nella forma di fiume, aveva
attraversato il mare mantenendo la purezza delle
sue acque.
(4) Il
tipo della quadriga esalta la partecipazione
dell'aristocrazia siracusana alle competizioni
olimpiche.
(5) L'etnico ΣΥΡAKOΣIΩN
(dei siracusani) indica che la moneta è stata
emessa nel nome del popolo di Siracusa. |