Roma, 17.3.2022
Egregio
Lettore,
di seguito riporto gli elementi significativi
riguardanti la moneta di figura:
Triente1,
zecca di Roma, dopo il 211 a. C.2, Crawford
56/4 (pag. 159), Sydenham
143b (pag. 15),
numismatica classica R-B7/4-1, indice di rarità
"(4)"
Descrizione sommaria (sono indicate in rosso le
parti della leggenda usurate o comunque non più
leggibili):
D. Minerva3, testa
elmata a destra, sopra oooo4.
R. Prua di nave a destra, sopra ROMA5,
sotto oooo.
La ricerca nel web di monete della tipologia di figura
ha dato luogo ai seguenti risultati:
- https://www.elsen.eu/Auction-149/-180-257-REPUBLIQUE-ROMAINE-ROMAN-REPUBLIC/emodule/5321/eitem/126831
Auction 149(180-257) REPUBLIQUE ROMAINE - ROMAN
REPUBLIC 182. Emission anonyme, AE triens, après
211 av. J.-C., Rome. D/ T. casquée de Minerve à d.
Au-dessus, quatre globules. R/ Proue à d.
Au-dessus, ROMA. En dessous, quatre globules. Cr.
56/4; Syd. 143b. 7,88g Patine brune. Très Beau
(Very Fine). €100.
- https://auctions.nomismaweb.com/en/lot/590482/anonime-triens-dopo-il-211-ac-testa-di-/
LOT 7 - E-LIVE AUCTION 21 Anonime - Triens (dopo
il 211 a.C.) Testa di Minerva a d. - R/ Prua a d.,
sopra, ROMA – Cr. 56/4 AE (g 5,00).
Grading/Status: MB. Aggiudicazioni dell’Asta
e-Live 21 del 6 e 7 marzo 2021 80,00€.
- vcoins
Anonymous Triens. Triens, 8.55g. Rome. Minerva,
Galley, four pellets. €159.18 Rates for: 03/16/22
Anonymous Triens. Obverse: Helmeted head of
Minerva right, four pellets above. Reverse: Galley
prow right, ROMA above, four pellets below. Mint
City: Rome. Struck After 211 BC. Reference: Cr.
56/4.
- https://www.acsearch.info/search.html?id=1266189
Heidelberger Münzhandlung Herbert Grün e.K.
http://www.hdmhg.de/ Auction 59 180 15.05.2012
Description Römische Münzen RÖMISCHE REPUBLIK -
Anonym Triens, nach 211 v. Chr. Minervakopf /
Prora, jeweils vier Wertkugeln. Cr. 56/4 4,47g
grüne Patina, ss.
- https://www.numisbids.com/n.php?p=lot&sid=1890&lot=395
VAuctions Triskeles Sale 19 17 March 2017 Lot 395
Estimate: 75 USD. Price realized: 75 USD.
Anonymous. After 211 BC. Æ triens (22mm, 6.27g,
4h). Uncertain mint in Italy. Helmeted head of
Minerva right; above, [four pellets] / [ROMA] in
exergue, prow of galley right; above, four
pellets. Cf. Crawford 56/4 (pellets and ROMA
switched); cf. Sydenham 143b. Extremely rare and
unpublished variety. Porous earthen-green patina.
Fine. A duplicate from the RBW Collection of Roman
Republican Coins. Purchased privately from
Artemide Aste, May 2008. An unpublished variety of
Crawford 56/4, with the pellets above the prow and
(presumably) ROMA below.
- https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=299498
364, Lot: 65. Estimate $100. Sold for $90.
Anonymous. After 211 BC. Æ Triens (21mm, 5.36g,
6h). Uncertain mint. Helmeted head of Minerva
right; four pellets above / Prow right; four
pellets below. Cf. Crawford 56/4; Sydenham 143b;
RBW 208. VF, green patina. From the RBW
Collection. Ex UBS 59 (29 January 2004), lot 6126.
Quoting a note by Roberto Russo in the RBW
catalog: “This...belong[s] to an anonymous light
series which includes triens, quadrans and
sextans. In our opinion, this series was not
identified by Crawford. The coins in this series
are always overstruck and almost always on
Sardo-Punic coins. Not only does this serve as
unequivocal proof that they should be dated
slightly after 212 and that the mint is Sardinian,
but it also confirms the fiduciary value of bronze
and proves that the light and heavy series were
entirely contemporaneous. The Sardinian
populations were accustomed to a fiduciary system
which would explain why they decided to use the
flans of the abundant Sardo-Punic bronze coins
already at their disposal rather than melt them
down to produce new flans of more precise weight.”
McCabe (“The anonymous struck bronze coinage of
the Roman Republic,” Essays Russo, p. 176), has
called into question the claim that these coins
are always struck on Sardo-Punic coins. He notes:
“The presence of certainly Italian and Sicilian
undertypes, as well as the fact that some are
overstrikes on earlier Roman coins makes the
picture less certain. It may be that they come
from more than one mint in Sardinia, southern
Italy and/or Sicily.”
- https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=299499
364, Lot: 66. Estimate $100. Sold for $200.
Anonymous. After 211 BC. Æ Triens (20mm, 4.94g,
7h). Uncertain mint. Helmeted head of Minerva
right; four pellets above / Prow right; four
pellets above. Cf. Crawford 56/4; Sydenham 143b;
RBW 208. Good VF, brown surfaces. From the RBW
Collection. Ex UBS 59 (29 January 2004), lot 6126.
Quoting a note by Roberto Russo in the RBW
catalog: “This...belong[s] to
an anonymous light series which includes triens,
quadrans and sextans. In our opinion, this series
was not identified by Crawford. The coins in this
series are always overstruck and almost always on
Sardo-Punic coins. Not only does this serve as
unequivocal proof that they should be dated
slightly after 212 and that the mint is Sardinian,
but it also confirms the fiduciary value of bronze
and proves that the light and heavy series were
entirely contemporaneous. The Sardinian
populations were accustomed to a fiduciary system
which would explain why they decided to use the
flans of the abundant Sardo-Punic bronze coins
already at their disposal rather than melt them
down to produce new flans of more precise weight.”
McCabe (“The anonymous struck bronze coinage of
the Roman Republic,” Essays Russo, p. 176), has
called into question the claim that these coins
are always struck on Sardo-Punic coins. He notes:
“The presence of certainly Italian and Sicilian
undertypes, as well as the fact that some are
overstrikes on earlier Roman coins makes the
picture less certain. It may be that they come
from more than one mint in Sardinia, southern
Italy and/or Sicily.”
- coins.ha.com
Description: Anonymous issues. After 211 BC. AE
triens (5.65g). Fine. Uncertain mint. Helmeted
head of Minerva right; four pellets above / ROMA,
prow right; four pellets below. Cf. Crawford 56/4.
Sydenham 143b. RBW 208. Quoting a note by Roberto
Russo in the RBW catalog: "This...belong[s] to an
anonymous light series which includes triens,
quadrans and sextans. In our opinion, this series
was not identified by Crawford. The coins in this
series are always overstruck and almost always on
Sardo-Punic coins. Not only does this serve as
unequivocal proof that they should be dated
slightly after 212 and that the mint is Sardinian,
but it also confirms the fiduciary value of bronze
and proves that the light and heavy series were
entirely contemporaneous. The Sardinian
populations were accustomed to a fiduciary system
which would explain why they decided to use the
flans of the abundant Sardo-Punic bronze coins
already at their disposal rather than melt them
down to produce new flans of more precise weight.
"McCabe ("The anonymous struck bronze coinage of
the Roman Republic," Essays Russo, p. 176), has
called into question the claim that these coins
are always struck on Sardo-Punic coins. He notes:
"The presence of certainly Italian and Sicilian
undertypes, as well as the fact that some are
overstrikes on earlier Roman coins makes the
picture less certain. It may be that they come
from more than one mint in Sardinia, southern
Italy and/or Sicily."
- https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=322897
385, Lot: 405. Estimate $150. Sold for $200.
Anonymous. After 211 BC. Æ Quadrans (22mm, 7.32g,
6h). Second Punic War half-weight, overstrike
series. Mint in Sardinia. Helmeted head of Minerva
right; •••• (mark of value) above / Prow of galley
right; •••• (mark of value) below. Crawford 56/4
var. (full weight, not overstruck); Sydenham –;
Type as RBW 207; McCabe Group H1. VF, dark brown
surfaces with touches of green. Well struck. From
the Andrew McCabe Collection.
Cr. 56/4 variety, half-weight anonymous triens.
McCabe (Essays Russo, 2013) pp. 175-180, type H1,
very similar die style to coin H1.Tr.7, which
shows clear overstrike evidence, thus this coin is
most likely a Sardinian or Sicilian Second Punic
War overstrike. [A. McCabe].
- https://auctions.bertolamifinearts.com/en/lot/68485/anonymous-sardinia-after-211-bc-triens-/
LOT 483 - E-LIVE AUCTION 80 Anonymous, Sardinia,
after 211 BC. Æ Triens (21mm, 5.28g, 7h). Helmeted
head of Minerva r. R/ Prow of galley r. Crawford
56/4; RBW 207-8. Good Fine.
Concludo osservando che, per quanto consentito ad una
valutazione a distanza, la moneta di figura presenta
caratteristiche fisiche, generali e di stile non
difformi da quelle delle monete d'epoca di pari
tipologia; se autentica, nel presente stato di
conservazione, il valore venale potrebbe, a mio
avviso, aggirarsi sui 20€.
Un saluto cordiale.
Giulio De Florio
--------------------------
Note:
(1) Il triente della tipologia di
figura appartiene alla serie cosiddetta "anonima"
perché priva di segni distintivi. Il peso standard
della serie è basato, secondo il Crawford, su un
asse di 54g, progressivamente degradante a
45-40,5g. Il sito Numismatica
Classica sottolinea l'ampio spettro di
variazione delle caratteristiche fisiche della
serie (diametro: 20-26mm, peso: 3,56-17,37g), ciò
che induce alcuni a parlare
di moneta fiduciaria ovvero moneta nella quale il
peso non ne determina il valore. Raccolgo in
tabella le caratteristiche fisiche dei trienti
della tipologia di figura reperiti nel web:
Riferimenti |
Peso(g.) |
Asse di conio(h) |
Diametro(mm) |
Link1 |
7,88 |
- |
- |
Link2 |
5,00 |
- |
- |
Link3 |
8,55 |
- |
- |
Link4 |
4,47 |
- |
- |
Link5 |
6,27 |
4 |
22 |
Link6 |
5,36 |
6 |
21 |
Link7 |
4,94 |
7 |
20 |
Link8 |
5,65 |
- |
- |
Link9 |
4,47 |
6 |
17 |
Link10 |
5,28 |
7 |
21 |
Dalla tabella si evince che le
caratteristiche fisiche del triente di figura (4,9g,
21,3mm, 9h) rientrano nei margini di variazione
delle monete d'epoca dello stesso tipo.
(2) Nel 211 a. C. i Romani
liberarono Sagunto che Annibale aveva conquistato
otto anni prima. Per poter competere sui mercati
meridionali dove già circolava la moneta d'argento
greca e cartaginese, Roma aggiunse un nuovo nominale
alla monetazione di bronzo, il denario d'argento.
Secondo l'opinione più diffusa tra gli studiosi ciò
avvenne proprio nel 211 a.C., v. link.
I nominali in bronzo della serie comprendevano:
- dupondio, Minerva, testa elmata di elmo
corinzio a destra/Prua di nave a destra, sopra II,
sotto ROMA,
v.
Cr. 56/1 [Roma manca nella foto; n.d.r.];
- asse, Giano, testa laureata, sopra I/ Prua
di nave a destra, sopra I, sotto ROMA, v.
Cr. 56/2;
- semisse, Saturno, testa laureata a destra,
dietro S
o
o / Prua di nave a destra, sopra S, sotto ROMA, v.
Cr. 56/3;
- triente, Minerva, testa elmata di elmo
corinzio a destra, sopra oooo/ Prua di nave a
destra, sopra ROMA,
sotto oooo,
v.
Cr. 56/4;
- quadrante, Ercole con leonté, testa a destra;
dietro / Prua di
nave a destra, sopra ROMA, sotto ooo, v.
Cr. 56/5;
- sestante, Mercurio, testa a destra, sopra oo/ Prua
di nave a destra, sopra ROMA, sotto oo, v.
Cr. 56/6;
- oncia, Roma, testa elmata di elmo attico a
destra; dietro o/
Prua di nave a destra, sopra ROMA,
sotto o
v.
Cr. 56/7;
- semuncia, Mercurio testa a destra;/ Prua di
nave a destra, sopra ROMA, v.
Cr. 56/8.
(3) L'immagine di Minerva con il
capo coperto dall'elmo distingue il triente dagli
altri nominali.
(4) oooo è il segno del valore
associato alla moneta, quattro once, un terzo di
asse, di qui il nome "triente".
(5) ROMA
è l'etnico, lo stato nel nome del quale la moneta è
stata battuta.
|