Roma, 7.4.2009
Egregio
Lettore,
la monetazione
greca non rientra nel campo di mia pertinenza, che è
quello delle monete romane. Ciò nondimeno, a
titolo puramente collaborativo, senza pretesa di
rigore scientifico, ho raccolto, attraverso una
ricerca nel web, alcuni elementi attinenti al tema in
discussione che di seguito espongo:
Tetradrammo
(AR)1, zecca di Atene, 454-415 a. C., Head
pag. 369
Descrizione
sommaria:
D. Testa di Atena a destra dall'occhio
frontale, con elmo attico crestato, decorato con
palmetta a spirale sulla calotta e con tre foglie di
ulivo sopra la visiera, pendente circolare
all'orecchio.
R. Civetta stante a destra di tre quarti, testa
frontale, rametto d'ulivo e crescente lunare dietro.
Davanti ΑΘΕ2. Tutto in quadrato incuso.
La ricerca
nel web di monete di tipologia identica a quella di
figura ha prodotto i seguenti risultati:
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=4749
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
93 ( « | » ) Price 26000 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(16.87 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 475-465 BC. Head
of Athena right, with frontal eye and wavy hair
above forehead, in crested Attic helmet ornamented
with three olive leaves above visor and spiral
palmette on bowl, wearing round earring with
central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl standing three-quarters
right, olive sprig and crescent moon behind,
outlines of square die visible. Starr Group II C.
cf. pl. viii, 69. Extremely rare. Exquisite,
perfectly centered head of Athena in extremely
high relief. Some porosity on reverse. About
extremely fine/good very fine. Displayed at
Cincinnati Art Museum, 1994-2008, no. 22. Acquired
from Harlan J. Berk, July 1995. This coin is from
Starr Group II, the small class of Athenian
tetradrachms struck after the battle of Marathon.
Group II C, to which this tetradrachm belongs,
also included the famous Athenian decadrachms. The
Group II tetradrachms are much rarer than those of
Starr Group IV or V. Estimate: US$10000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5035
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
94 ( « | » ) Price 3250 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(17.15 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 465/2 BC. Head of
Athena right, with frontal eye and smooth loop of
hair over forehead, in crested Attic helmet
ornamented with three olive leaves above visor and
spiral palmette on bowl, wearing round earring
with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl with three tail
feathers standing three-quarters right, olive
sprig and crescent moon behind, outlines of square
die visible. Starr Group V A, cf. pl. xvii, 172.
Cf. Kraay-Hirmer 361. Beautiful owl head.
Extremely fine.
Displayed at Cincinnati Art Museum, 1994-2008, no.
23 (reverse illustrated in guide). Acquired from
Harlan J. Berk, October 1976. Estimate: US$5000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5036
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
95 ( « | » ) Price 5250 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(17.19 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 454 BC. Head of
Athena right, with frontal eye and smooth loop of
hair over forehead, in crested Attic helmet
ornamented with three olive leaves above visor and
spiral palmette on bowl, wearing round earring
with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl with small eyes and
"prong" tail standing three-quarters right, olive
sprig and crescent moon behind, outlines of square
die visible. Starr pl. xxii, 3'. Svoronos pl. 12,
1-11. Unexpectedly beautiful high relief
tetradrachm of the post-Starr groups. Mint state.
Acquired from Harlan J. Berk, December 1986.
Estimate: US$5000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5037
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
96 ( « | » ) Price 8000 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(17.17 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 454-430 BC. Head
of Athena right, with frontal eye and smooth loop
of hair over forehead, in crested Attic helmet
ornamented with three olive leaves above visor and
spiral palmette on bowl, wearing round earring
with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl with "prong" tail
standing three-quarters right, olive sprig and
crescent moon behind, outlines of square die
visible. Cf. Starr pl. xxii, 6'. Cf. Svoronos pl.
12, 16; pl. 13, 5-9. Beautifully modeled high
relief obverse and reverse. Finest style. Mint
state. Displayed at Cincinnati Art Museum,
1994-2008, no. 25. Acquired from Harlan J. Berk,
December 1990. Estimate: US$4000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5038
Gemini, LLC > Auction V Auction date: 6 January
2009 Lot number: 97 Price realized: 5,250
USD Note: Prices do not include
buyer's fees. Lot description: Attica. Athens.
Silver tetradrachm (16.81 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca.
454-430 BC. Head of Athena right, with frontal eye
and smooth loop of hair over forehead, in crested
Attic helmet ornamented with three olive leaves
above visor and spiral palmette on bowl, wearing
round earring with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl with
"prong" tail standing three-quarters right, olive
sprig and crescent moon behind, outlines of square
die visible. Cf. Starr pl. xxii, 2' (obverse) and
6'(reverse). Cf. Svoronos pl. 13, 4-6. Perfectly
centered and of wonderful style. Mint state.
Acquired from Harlan J. Berk, October
1987.Estimate: US$3000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5041
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
100 ( « | » ) Price 1900 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(17.15 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 393-350 BC. Head
of Athena right with profile eye in crested Attic
helmet ornamented with three olive leaves above
visor and spiral palmette on bowl, wearing round
earring with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl of late style
standing three-quarters right, olive sprig and
crescent moon behind. Svoronos pl. 21, 24-26.
Excellent example of this normally carelessly
struck issue. Extremely fine. Acquired from Harlan
J. Berk, January 1985. Estimate: US$750.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=5042
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
101 ( « | » ) Price 500 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(17.19 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 350-294 BC. Head
of Athena right with profile eye in crested Attic
helmet ornamented with three olive leaves above
visor and spiral palmette of "pi" style on bowl,
wearing round earring with central boss / ΑΘΕ, owl
of late style standing three-quarters right, olive
sprig and crescent moon behind. Nicolet- Pierre
and Kroll, AJN 2 (1990), pl. i, pi-1-pi-4.
Svoronos pl. 20. Toned extremely fine. Displayed
at Cincinnati Art Museum, 1994-2008, no. 26.
Acquired from Harlan J. Berk, May 1988. Estimate:
US$500.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=7616
Source Hess-Divo AG Auction 309 (28.04.2008) Lot
56 ( « | » ) Price 800 CHF (~774
USD) Description GREEK COINS ATTICA ATHENS.
Imitation of an Athenian Tetradrachm (Silver)
circa 400 BC, uncertain Eastern mint. Head of
Athena right, wearing crested Attic helmet adorned
with three olive leaves over visor and a palmette
on the bowl / / AQ[E]. Owl standing right, head
facing, olive spray and crescent behind; all
within incuse square. Starr -; Svoronos -; SNG ANS
-; SNG Cop. -. 16.79 g. Extremely rare.
Extremely fine The high quality of this imitation,
as well as its fabric, suggest a mint in either
Phoenicia or Philisto-Arabia. "Carrying owls to
Athens" In the ancient world, the Athenian
Tetradrachms belonged to one of the most widely
circulated currencies. Like the U.S. Dollar in our
times, the Athenian Tetradrachms were widely
accepted around the Meditaranean and the frontier
regions of the Near East. Its popularity was based
on the longterm stability of the finesse of silver
and the high volume of mintage. The silver for the
production of the Athenian Tetradrachms originated
from the rich mines of Laurion. Like any well
known brand today, the Athenian Tetradrachms with
the recurring motif of the head of Athena on one
side and the owl on the other side, were soon
imitated by various local authorities. The coin on
offer here, is an excellent example of such an
imitation done in remarkable style. Estimate: 1000
CHF.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=7699
Source Classical Numismatic Group, Inc. Auction
Triton XI (08.01.2008) Lot 335 ( «
| » ) Price 2000 USD Description PHARONIC
KINGS of EGYPT. Uncertain pharaoh. Time of the
28th-30th dynasties, circa 400-350 BC. AR
Tetradrachm (17.03 g, 9h). Imitating Athens. Head
of Athena right, wearing crested Attic helmet
decorated with three olive leaves over visor and a
spiral palmette on the bowl / AQE, owl standing
right, head facing; olive sprig and crescent
behind; all within incuse square. Flament style X;
Van Alfen pl. 11. EF, light earthen dusting.
Exceptional preservation and metal. Prior to the
introduction of Macedonian issues beginning in the
late fourth century BC, Egypt relied upon the use
of imitations of Athenian tetradrachms for its
international transactions. Although its presence
as a major power in the eastern Mediterranean
extended over two millennia, Egypt had never
struck its own currency, relying instead on
payment-in-kind and specie payments. By the end of
the sixth century BC, the presence of Greek
traders drastically altered this arrangement.
Beginning with the establishment of Naukratis in
the Delta, Greek coin-types, along with a steady
supply of silver, flowed into Lower Egypt. There
some of this material was melted and re-struck
into into more localized imitative types, which
then circulated into Phoenicia and points
eastward. One is the 1989 Syria Hoard, containing
numerous examples of these imitative types, as
well as examples from the final period of Egypt as
a Persian satrapy. Although the Persian Empire
already had a long and well-established monetary
system, these imitative Athenian tetrdrachms
circulated in areas in which they were already a
recognized and accepted currency, allowing the
satrapy of Egypt to continue its trade in those
areas unimpeded. For a more detailed discussion of
Athenian imitations in Egypt, see P. van Alfen,
“Owls From the 1989 Syria Hoard,” AJN Second
Series, 14 (2002), pp. 1-58. Estimate: 1000 USD.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=9816
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
91 ( « | » ) Price 47500 USD
Description Attica. Athens. Silver tetradrachm
(16.70 gm). Attica. Athens, Ca. 515-510 BC. Head
of Athena right with frontal eye, finely modeled
cheek, and curved bangs ending in small curls, in
crested Attic helmet ornamented with spiral at
back of bowl, wearing round earring with central
pellet / ΑΘΕ, owl standing three-quarters right,
five leaf olive sprig behind, outline of square
die visible. Seltman Group L, 344 (A224/P286), pl.
xv. Svoronos pl. 6, 16 (same dies). Asyut Group
III, 261-265. Extremely rare. Reverse somewhat
weakly struck. Extremely fine/very fine. Displayed
at Cincinnati Art Museum, 1994-2008, no. 20
(obverse illustrated in guide). Acquired from
Harlan J. Berk, December 1986. This tetradrachm
comes from a group that Seltman ascribed to the
"civic mint" and placed wrongly at the end of the
pre-Marathon issues of Athens. Tetradrachms of
Seltman's Groups H and L have turned up in hoards
with gorgoneion tetradrachms, the last of the
Wappenmunzen types, providing evidence that
Seltman's Groups H and L were the earliest of the
Athenian "owls." The head of Athena on the obverse
of this coin is so intense and so sensitively
modeled that it has a sculptural quality
reminiscent of the East Greek korai found on the
Athenian Acropolis. The reverse shows an olive
sprig with multiple leaves that places this issue
firmly at the beginning of the "owl" series, when
the Athenians were still experimenting with
different variations on the Athena/owl types
before settling on the two-leaf olive sprig.
Estimate: US$50000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=9817
Source Gemini, LLC Auction V (06.01.2009) Lot
104 ( « | » ) Price 3000 USD
Description EASTERN IMITATION OF ATHENS. Silver
tetradrachm (16.82 gm). . , Probably before 490
BC. Head of Athena right in crested Attic helmet
ornamented with spiral on bowl / ΑΘΕ, owl standing
three-quarters right, olive sprig behind, outlines
of square die visible. Unpublished? Perfectly
centered extremely fine. Acquired from Harlan J.
Berk, February 1991. This coin is a contemporary
imitation of a pre-Marathon Athenian tetradrachm,
probably struck in Egypt or the Levant no later
than 490 BC.
Estimate: US$5000.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=9976
Source LHS Numismatik AG Auction 100 (23.04.2007)
Lot 245 ( « | » ) Price 10000
CHF (~8260 USD) Description Attica-Crete Athens,
Attica Estimate: CHF 4'500.00 Tetradrachm (Silver,
17.00 g 10), c. 490. Helmeted head of Athena to
right, with very prominent archaic features and a
large facing eye. Rev. [] Owl standing right, head
facing; to left, olive spray. Dewing 1588 var.
Seltman 57 ff. Svoronos pl. 2, 21. Fresh, of good
metal, and struck in high relief with an obverse
head of remarkable archaic style. Some minor
bangs, otherwise, good very fine. From the
collection of R. Maly, acquired from M. Dürr in
1975 and said to have been found in Sicily.
- http://www.acsearch.info/record.html?id=10251
Source Leu Numismatik AG Auction 83 (06.05.2002)
Lot 229 ( « | » ) Description
THE GREEK WORLD ATTICA Athens Estimate: CHF
9'500.00 Tetradrachm (Silver, 17.10g 3), c. 500.
Head of Athena to right, wearing plain Attic
helmet with crest indicated by a dotted zigzag
pattern, disc earring, and with her hair indicated
by lines ending in dotted spirals. Rev. Owl
standing to right, head facing; behind, olive
spray. Asyut 326 var. Seltman 405. SNG Lockett
1811. Svoronos pl. 4, 31 ff. An attractive,
well-struck example. About extremely fine.
Acquired in 1969 and very possibly ex Asyut, but
unrecorded.
Come già
osservato, il peso e il diametro della moneta sono
conformi a quelli delle monete autentiche del periodo.
Purtroppo le foto poco professionali di cui dispongo
non consentono un raffronto esaustivo con i campioni
di riferimento di cui sopra ho
fornito i link. Desta perplessità il luogo del
ritrovamento, la Magna Grecia, mentre si sa che i
tetradrammi erano monete battute ad Atene che non
avevano libera circolazione nell'area geografica nella
quale la moneta in esame è stata trovata. Qualche
differenza tra gli originali e la moneta di figura è
stato possibile rilevarla, ad esempio nella foto di
figura la dea mostra una tripla ondulazione dei
capelli sul lato del viso invece dei due canonici.
Inoltre la forma della moneta appare quasi circolare e
priva di spigoli, il che la differenzia un po' dalle
monete di riferimento. In considerazione dell'elevato
valore venale (deducibile dai prezzi sopra forniti),
la tipologia monetale in questione è tra le più
imitate dai falsari (v. ad esempio il
link) e ciò rende ancora più sospettosi
sull'autenticità del campione in esame.
Un saluto
cordiale.
Giulio De
Florio
-------------------------------
Note:
(1) Tetradrammo (argento). Raccolgo in
tabella le caratteristiche fisiche dei tetradrammi
della tipologia di figura tratte dai link di cui sopra:
Riferimenti |
Peso
(g.) |
Diametro
(mm) |
Asse di
conio (h) |
Link1 |
16,87 |
- |
- |
Link2 |
17,15 |
- |
- |
Link3 |
17,19 |
- |
- |
Link4 |
17,17 |
- |
- |
Link5 |
16,81 |
- |
- |
Link6 |
17,15 |
- |
6 |
Link7 |
17,19 |
- |
9 |
Link8 |
16,79 |
- |
- |
Link9 |
17,03 |
- |
9 |
Link10 |
16,70 |
- |
- |
Link11 |
16,82 |
- |
- |
Link12 |
17,00 |
- |
10 |
Link13 |
17,10 |
- |
3 |
Dalla tabella
si evince che il peso della moneta di figura (17g) si
presenta non difforme da quello delle monete
autentiche del periodo.
(2) ΑΘΕ è il segno di zecca di Atene. |